Copy Clinic: Rewriting a Weak Homepage Headline

A headline that could belong to any company, rewritten line by line until it could only belong to one, with the reasoning behind each change set out in full.

Run your own opening line through the Insight Injector Start your own brief with the Website Brief Starter

The brief

The brief behind this rewrite: a homepage headline for an invoicing tool built for UK sole traders and freelancers, people who already use an accounting app but still spend an evening a week chasing clients for payment by email. The headline sits above the fold, the part of the page a visitor sees before they scroll, so it has to earn the next click on its own. Nobody reads a homepage top to bottom the way they read an article. They read the headline, decide in a few seconds whether the page is talking to them, and either stay or leave.

The original headline

The version that arrived for review read: "Powerful software built to help your business grow." It is grammatical, it is polite, and it fails the one test a homepage headline has to pass. Swap it onto a CRM, a gym franchise, an insurance broker or a project management tool, and it still reads as if it belongs there. A headline that survives being moved to a different industry unchanged was never written for this one.

The rewrite

The rewritten version: "Invoice a UK client in under two minutes, and let automatic reminders chase the late ones." It names the reader's actual task, gives a specific figure, and states the outcome the reader is actually after. It could not be moved to a gym franchise without rewriting every word in it, which is the point of a homepage headline that is doing its job.

What changed, and why

  • "Powerful" is gone. It is a claim about quality with no evidence attached, and a reader has no way to check it, so it sits on the page doing nothing except taking up the first word.
  • "software" became "Invoice". The original named the category of product; the rewrite names the action the reader takes. A visitor scanning a homepage is looking for what they can do here.
  • "a UK client" was added. It tells a freelancer this tool understands UK invoicing, and it does that in three words.
  • "in under two minutes" replaced nothing, because the original made no equivalent claim at all. A specific figure gives the reader something to weigh; a headline with no number in it is asking to be taken on trust.
  • "help your business grow" became "let automatic reminders chase the late ones". Growth is an ambition nobody can picture; chasing a late invoice is a Tuesday afternoon the reader has actually had. This is the difference between a feature and a benefit: the reminder function is the feature, and not having to send the email yourself is the benefit.

The principle

Read the original headline back and ask whether a competitor's homepage could carry it unchanged. If the answer is yes, the headline is describing the category, and it is spending the one sentence a visitor reads before deciding to leave on saying nothing they could not have guessed. A homepage headline that names the reader's actual task, states a specific outcome, and could only sit above this one product is doing the job the space was built for. The full mechanics of building a homepage around that opening line, including how the rest of the page carries on from it, are set out in the guide to writing a homepage.

The same gap probably sits in your own homepage headline

The tool checks a headline for the specifics that make it belong to one company. It works from patterns in the wording, so it can flag the wrong thing or miss the right one. Treat what it gives you as a prompt to check.